
It's probably not that surprising that an American Apparel advert has been banned. For the last few years they've consistently produced adverts featuring young women spread-eagled in their boyfriend's underwear, on all fours in hot-pants or topless in gym wear. It's not clever or interesting, just quite grim when you consider that the CEO, Dov Charney, has been accused of sexual harassment and once masturbated in front of a female journalist.
The reason it's been banned is that the woman looks as if she is under sixteen, and also because it is said to resemble an 'amateur-style photo shoot'. I'm not sure if I think the model looks THAT young, but the latter part is true. American Apparel have claimed the ad demonstrated that the hoodie is "soft to the touch" and that the model was not supposed to be viewed as"a sex object or in a negative or derogatory light". (Ta, Guardian) I'm sure I'm not alone in finding that hard to believe. After all, these photographs show a young woman gradually gradually revealing that she's topless under a hoodie whilst wearing teeny tiny shorts.
But it's not the most controversial of their adverts that I've seen. Check out this. I wonder if they would also claim that this was not sexual? When I first heard about this story, I really thought (hoped) it would be this one that had been banned. I'm sure that none of the models are actually under age, Ryan from the banned advert is 23, but they point is that they look young and vulnerable which is unsettling to say the least.
They've also tried to justify the ad by saying that because it ran in Vice magazine, it was unlikely to cause offense. I would agree that the ad won't have been the most sexist, offensive part of Vice. In fact, using very young looking women wearing very little in their photo shoots is something that the magazine is pretty obsessed with. A recent issue featured an extremely young and ill looking woman in a little blue swimming costume, playing about like a child. Ew. There's certainly a weird Lolita-esque thing going on in hipster lifestyle catalogues these days. The models appear as children, but are posed so as to that suggest they would be crazy in bed. Again, ew.
American Apparel has been lauded for the ethical way it treats it's LA base labour force, and this is certainly commendable. However, the way the women on its workforce are constantly simultaneously sexualised and infantilsed in its advertising is reprehensible. I guess it's understandable in a society that still wants women to be subservient and pure, but also up for having sex all the time. These American Apparel adverts are nothing more than pictorial representations of this tension and they deserve a collective 'YUCK' from the women they want to sell to.
Sunday, 6 September 2009
Want to be a hipster girlfriend? Look like a child.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

I think I agree that she doesn't look under 16 (though the modelling industry fetishizes young-prepubescent looking models, it would be a step in the wrong direction to deny models work appropriate to their real age, because of the age they appear). It's the facial expression in conjunction with the content that gets me - it displays a kind of vulnerability. That might be a factor in why people think she looks young, perhaps).
ReplyDeleteBy contrast I find the other ad campaign to be more outright unsettling but the facial expressions less so. Less pathetic, more predatory? Well, maybe it could be read that way if it was an art project or co-ord by women, but I doubt that's the case here!
dude, they are actually using porn stars too now, like sasha grey among many others. And thet have this one racist ad that makes me so angry....
ReplyDeletehttp://stylecrave.com/2009-09-03/american-apparel-ads-the-50-hottest-in-company-history/
ReplyDeletesome of these ads are unbelievable; and of course deemed 'sexy' by the men that are hooked on this fantasy.
hi
ReplyDeletebridal online shop bridal gowns wholesale wedding dresses high quality bridal gowns wholesale custom wedding dresses wedding apparel wedding dresses top sellers wedding dresses2010 new arrivals 2010 new arrivals wedding dresses beach wedding dresses Luxury Wedding Dresses plus size wedding dresses wedding party dresses bridesmaid dresses junior bridesmaid dresses flower girl dresses mother of bride dresses wedding shoes wedding bags wedding accessories evening dresses prom dresses cocktail dresses quinceanera dresses little black dresses
ReplyDeleteImpression bridal gowns Interlude bridal gowns Jacquelin Exclusive bridal gowns Jasmine bridal gowns JLM Couture bridal gowns Joli Bridal bridal gowns Jordan Fashions bridal gowns Justin Alexander bridal gowns La Richi bridal gowns La Sposa bridal gowns Lady Roi bridal gowns Landa bridal gowns LIS SIMON bridal gowns Liz Fields bridal gowns Macis Design bridal gowns Maggie Sottero bridal gowns Marisa Bridals bridal gowns Martina Liana bridal gowns Mia Solano bridal gowns Mikaella bridal gowns Mon Cheri bridal gowns Moonlight bridal gowns Mori Lee bridal gowns Nika bridal gowns Niki bridal gowns Paloma Blanca bridal gowns
ReplyDeleteRaylia Designs bridesmaid dresses Romantic Bridals bridesmaid dresses Saison Blanche bridesmaid dresses Val Stefani bridesmaid dresses Venus Bridal bridesmaid dresses Watters bridesmaid dresses WTOO bridesmaid dresses A-Line bridesmaid dresses Ball Gown bridesmaid dresses Column bridesmaid dresses Empire bridesmaid dresses Mermaid bridesmaid dresses Princess bridesmaid dresses Sheath bridesmaid dresses Trumpet bridesmaid dresses Bateau bridesmaid dresses
ReplyDelete